ALL SECULAR PAKISTANIS NEED TO UNITE 

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

 Dear Khalid

 

Thank you for your kind comments. I feel privileged to be permitted to make postings. As a newcomer, I was confused by the format of the website. I assumed that your article "Humanity at a Crossroads" was presented, perhaps as a speech, at the seminar. That was my reason for commenting on aspects of it that I disagreed with.

 

When I look now at the introduction to the seminar, I read "The other half [of the world] is fighting an economic war against imperialism." You ask me what I would contribute to such a seminar. The problem for me, Khalid, is that I do not for a moment accept this fundamental premise; I consider it nonsense. How could I speak at a seminar at which all contributors appear to assume the truth of something I reject?

 

I am not sure why you are confused by this. In my postings, I have tried to explain my reasons in as clear and detailed a manner as I can. First, that I do not accept that Christian and Muslim fundamentalists are equal threats; secondly, that I reject the idea that any nation has a "war economy"; thirdly, that I do not believe in the existence of western imperialism in the modern world (I have another posting to make on this issue, which should be finished soon).

 

I am not seeking to be the skunk at the picnic; I am just expressing my views as clearly as I can. I don't necessarily expect everyone to agree with them, but they might at least be food for thought. I get the impression that you are all secular Muslims, but perhaps I have misunderstood the political makeup of the group members. Are you all socialists, perhaps? But I don't know why a secular Muslim would have to be a socialist.

 

Regards

Peter Joyce 

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart