ALL SECULAR PAKISTANIS NEED TO UNITE 

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

After reading Jawaid Chaudhry  commentary, I re-read all the speeches and could not figure out why JC says the speakers were off topic. Perhaps he was talking about Arif Raza and Dr. Amjad, whose speeches are missing, but both Tarek Fatah and Hamid Bashani addressed the topic while Khalid Sohail set the tempo.

 

How can we discuss imperialism without discussing Mark Twain or what he had to say on the subject? I also could not understand his objection to Tarek Fatah talking about Pervez Hoodbhoy and Tariq Ali. The two were featured in the masthead of the FOTH page dedicated to this seminar.

 

Tarek's speech reveals a deep understanding of the flaw in leftists backing Islamists and his reference to Lenin's warnings about "mullahs" was something I didn't know about. I didn't know Franz Fanon was Algerian either, so thank you for sharing the text of Tarek Fatah's speech.

 

What did Arif Raza say and who was it who defended suicide bombings?

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart