Mutual Influence of the Metaphysical and Physical

By: Ziauddin Ahmed

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

Parroting the Big Lie

My dear Feroz,

Your allusion to "the universe with countless trillions of heavenly bodies spinning in an orbit" could be one big illusion -- what Hindus have for 5,000 years called maya and what scientists are now beginning to acknowledge with the aid of Einstein's Theory of Relativity.

You should at least entertain the possibility that the universe is a-whirl because your own planet is spinning.

Have a sense of humour.

Relax.

It's not your fault.

You should entertain the possibility that everything is relative (the 'E equals MC squared' of this discussion) and not half as absolute as you make out your opinions (or beliefs) to be.

Don't forget that we've slugged it out over the same argument on Writers Forum a few years ago. Even then you gave the impression that your beliefs were facts.

I maintain that if anyone tells you what God has planned out for you, that person is lying.

If you tell me that God wants me to do this, that and the other, I will say you are telling me what everyone else tells everyone else -- culturally, historically, religiously, and traditionally.

The point I am making is that you're propagating the Big Lie, because you yourself have not experienced anything new or different from what we all know as well.

Some people simply refuse to buy the Big Lie (and you probably call them al-Kafirun), whereas many people find it fashionable to become colourful parrots of The Big Lie (and you probably call them al-Ulema).

Finally, if you know, as you claim, "that with a close-minded attitude one remains hopelessly trapped in wasteful discussions with no hope of any real progress," why then are you wasting your time in this discussion by pretending to be a true intellectual?

I would like to appreciate your honesty and integrity in seeing what another person is saying.

Rashid Mughal

 

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart