Two Psychiatrist

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

 

Sohail;
A couple of ideas after reading your mail. It is axiomatic that no one book (or even several) can ever capture the total essence of a person, especially one who participated in significant historical events of his or her lifetime. Any book, essay, TV program, movie etc is but a snapshot that captures an aspect of a person. I do not think, therefore, that we need to concern ourselves with writing the 'definitive' biography of Faiz or his work. Rather, we shall hope that it is a useful contribution to the Faiz literature already in existence and serves as a starting point for other writers in the future.
It seems that your library of Faiz books is much larger than mine, so please do send me the interview that you mentioned. I have read several 'overviews' that Faiz gave of his life and artistic development including one just a few months before his death so I am familiar with the broad outlines but would be very interested in another view.

I am very happy about this exchange and how it simplifies, for future authors, the process of beginning to write a book. When, in the past, I have read essays, lectures and books by socialist/Marxist activists, the thing that has impressed me most is their refusal to bow to authority including authority claimed from scholarship, learning etc. In other words, they would not be intimidated by so called 'experts' thus practically, in real life, demonstrating their commitment to common people.

I have only met Sheema a time or two many years ago. She, too, is a living breathing example of how we are all 'standing on the shoulders of giants' and how, if it were not for the hard work and dedication of ordinary people who continue to serve their craft without regard for the rewards of fame and money, there would not exist a Faiz, an Iqbal, a Ghalib, a Sartre, Marx or Che Guevara. You pointed out in a chapter of 'Samaaji Tabdeeli' that some people by virtue of their craft become a symbol of their age which I think is absolutely true. It is also true that they are only able to do this because of the toil and dedication of countless others who never become as celebrated but yet are just as crucial to the 'finished product'.

Let us  hope our little endeavor will also be a small contribution to this journey.

(I will point out with a smile that the Sufi way actually discourages beginning a journey without a master so perhaps it is not quite as democratic. It is true though that 'when the student is ready, the master will appear')

Ali

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart