Two Psychiatrist

Family of the Heart - DIALOGUE & DISCUSSIONS 

Sohail;

 

Thank you for sending me your essay on 'Psychology of Spiritual Encounters'. As I said before, I am impressed by your courage in attempting to understand critique and advance these very broad, sometimes nebulous ideas and make them accessible to the average non-medical reader.

Regarding the deeper meaning of psychosis (or 'madness' in lay terms), I have come to the conclusion that there is *always* a meaning to these 'symptoms' of hearing voices, having odd beliefs (delusions) etc. It has a meaning for those experiencing them, the challenge for the person as well as those trying to help him or her is to figure out a way to integrate this meaning into the larger context of a person's life and how that life fits into the society that person lives in. I have found that I can connect much better with people that I see if I help them accept those experiences as a part of themselves rather than something 'alien' that needs to be gotten rid of. Also, until we have a more firm scientific understanding of the bio-chemical causes of these symptoms, I am always reluctant to attribute them to Dopamine, Serotonin etc abnormalities. Here in the US, 'chemical imbalance' has become a much abused cliche now rendered meaningless because of its frequent use and misuse.

 

Your story about Dr.Honda was touching. I fully agree that mystical/spiritual experiences help develop a person's compassion and generosity. Looking at is from the other side (in dialectical Marxist fashion) though, I am sad that it requires such an experience to cultivate those qualities in a person. By definition, that means our societies as currently constructed discourage or suppress these qualities in favor of selfishness, acquisitiveness, possessiveness etc. How wonderful it would be if it could be the other way around.

 

The section on the role of Temporal Lobes in Spiritual and Creative Encounters was particularly interesting and heartening. If we humans do not destroy ourselves as a species and our Mother Earth along with us, I think we will continue to unmask these magical and mystic wonders through our scientific and creative endeavors.

I am a great admirer of Maslow as well, something I inherited (or perhaps imbibed) from my father who was a Psychology student in the US in the early 70s at the height of the counter culture movement and was a great admirer of all 'humanist' intellectuals.

I would also submit, in the end, that just as people with wealth and possessions do not hesitate to defend them, it is incumbent upon intellectuals, writers and all creative people to defend their 'wealth' as well, the wealth of their knowledge, their creativity and their understanding and disperse it as widely as possible. You are certainly in the lead as far as that is concerned.

 

Here is one of my essays that talks a little about Maslow.

http://www.chowk.com/articles/11824

 

I would love to collaborate with you on a book. You also need to tell me your secret of 'time management'. How do you find the time for so much reading and writing while working and having a presumably busy and involved social life?

 

Wassallaam,

 

Ali

  

Send questions or comments to Family of the Heart